Photojournalism and election night coverage at the Coloradoan

photograph by Rich Abrahamson, Coloradoan staff photographer, November 4, 2008photograph by Michael Seamans, Coloradoan staff photographer, November 4, 2008Election 2008
Shooting the story – or not: •Rich Abrahamson (04-Nov-08), Larimer County Republicans [portfolio of 8 photographs], Coloradoan, online at www.coloradoan.com (accessed 06-Nov-08). •Michael G. Seamans (05-Nov-08), Larimer County Democrats [portfolio of 13 photographs], Coloradoan, online (accessed 06-Nov-08).

Today's front page of the Coloradoan features a photograph of Betsy Markey. Yesterday the Coloradoan published the same photograph in an online portfolio. The photo doesn't improve with repeated viewing. It's haphazardly composed; brimming with spurious detail; didactic in its depiction of an election-night champagne toast; and almost mean-spirited in its unflattering presentation of its subjects. The photo looks like a snapshot rather than the work of a photojournalist.

Betsy Markey – the subject of the photo – won her election as the Northern Colorado Representative to the U.S. House, in a race that generated national interest. Many races in Colorado generated national interest this year. So, as election-night results came in and the defeat of regressive politics became more and more apparent, I wanted to see – as if I was there in the same room with the politicians themselves – what it all looked like. Especially for the races and politicians in Colorado, where we've been saying for many months that if Obama won Colorado, he'd win the election. I turned to my local newspaper – the Coloradoan – to view its online coverage and photographs. (By this time, it was the next morning.)

The Coloradoan published two online portfolios of election-night photographs, which I've hyperlinked above – one portfolio for the Republicans and one for the Democrats.

Rich Abrahamson photographed the Republican response to their night's election loses. His photos depict the disappointment and dignity of people who are seeing their hopes denied. (And when did someone ever capture such a sympathetic photo of Kevin Lundberg?)

Michael Seamans' photos of the Democrats – including his photos of Betsy Markey – pale by comparison.

I won't belabor the differences between Seamans' and Abrahamson's photos, but if you compare the two portfolios, you'll see how a photographer can bring us closer to an event or obscure it.


 

What did you think of this article?




Trackbacks
  • No trackbacks exist for this post.
Comments

  • Saturday, March 07, 2009 12:37 PM Michael wrote:
    Who wrote this article?
    Reply to this
  • Saturday, March 07, 2009 8:46 PM Jason wrote:
    Kind of easy to throw stones when you don't know what's going on in person, friend. As a photojournalist who was at the Larimer Dem party on Election Night I can tell you M. Seamans did a fine job. In fact, he was the only journalist who gained access to Markey's hotel suite before she came downstairs. But you wouldn't know that.

    Photojournalism is about composition, access, equipment, etc. To judge someone by one photo is lame. Also, did you know M. Seamans placed 3rd in the National Press Photographers Association yearly awarding for an 8 state region? He beat out numerous Rocky and Denver Post shooters on his way to the top.

    As a photojournalist, I can tell you he is one of the best in the state. But, something tells me you're only interested in throwing rocks. So, throw away.
    Reply to this
  • Sunday, March 08, 2009 6:02 AM 3D wrote:
    Thanks for taking the time to comment, Jason.

    I stand by my review of Seamans' election night portfolio.
    Reply to this
Leave a comment

 Enter the above security code (required)

 Name (required)

 Email (will not be published) (required)

Your comment is 0 characters limited to 3000 characters.